fanw ([info]fanw) wrote,
@ 2005-03-26 09:45:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
[Review] Emma -- Jane Austen
I finally picked up Jane Austen's Emma. I can't believe quite how long it's been since I read Austen. I absolutely loved Pride and Prejudice, but that was -- can it be? -- half a lifetime ago! I was very curious to see whether it would still strike me as strongly now.

I found Emma to be delightful. It was certainly a quick read, and I enjoyed watching her and Mr. Knightley play off of each other. Austen also has a talent for revealing characters in social situations. You need not know anything more about Mrs. Elton than the way she steamrolls a conversation and you have a perfect picture.

I did find Emma to be a little too familiar. That is, I could easily see myself making some of the same mistakes. I don't think I would have meddled nearly as much as she, but I certainly have been known to extrapolate wildly based on few facts. This is a practice that I have carefully learned to drop over the years. And vanity? I know a little something about that, or at least of pride.

Emma didn't reach me as Pride and Prejudice did at fifteen. There is something too incomplete in ending a book with marriage, after only infatuation and flirtation and before any of the meat of a relationship can be developed. For that I found Eliot's Middlemarch to be much more rich, but then again Eliot is a bit depressing and not nearly as overall entertaining as Austen. If I had wanted abject realism, I wouldn't have picked up such a sunny book as this.

And so, this book reminded me how lovely Austen is and how much I should reread Pride and Prejudice, and further, of the folly of my high school/college years. I can only hope that I do not lose all my folly with my yearly dose of wisdom. Otherwise, what will make my tears roll down in laughter when I'm 80 and looking back at my life? I hope there is still plenty of richness of feeling, both pain and pleasure, embarassment and unadulterated joy in my life to come.



(Post a new comment)


[info]ert
2005-03-27 01:52 am UTC (link)
Oooh! Here's where I can sound like a couch potato! I've never read Emma, but did quite enjoy the Gwenyth Paltrow film version about 10 years ago.

(Reply to this)


[info]jirikido
2005-03-27 06:43 pm UTC (link)
i freely admit that the novel of manners is a totally foreign concept to me, growing up in a poor scottish household. oddly enough, I found Fielding's Tom Jones more accessible initially, and a part of Eliot's Adam Beade in which he wanted to keep working while there was sunlight left, but the foreman he was working for wanted to stop at 6pm or something like that. I've often felt their like. I did come back to Pride and Prejudice after a time though.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]fanw
2005-03-28 05:27 am UTC (link)
I think it was just my wacky household that made me love comedies of manners. I mean, both parents were in drama and I feel I had a very Victorian education. I was required to learn an instrument and a foreign language, to know the Greek Gods by heart, and for years I carried things on my head in an effort to have good posture (though eventually I just really liked carrying things on my head). So although we were below the poverty line and ate lots of potatoes and things, we did read Thucydides in the evenings and discuss the succession of British kings. Somehow that just seemed normal.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]jirikido
2005-03-28 08:51 am UTC (link)
hehe, mmm, indeed, i have had a sense for a while that yours was a lovely left turn from a regular childhood and hooray for that :)

(Reply to this) (Parent)


Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…